Why Even Well-Executed A/B Tests Can Fail to Answer the Real Business Question
By
Suchitra
Summary
The article discusses how experiments (particularly A/B tests) often fail not because of technical execution, but because the experimental design cannot actually answer the business question being asked. It introduces the concept of "identifiability" — whether an experiment's design can truly isolate and measure the causal effect of interest. The author argues that as AI makes running experiments easier, the critical question shifts from "Can I run this test?" to "Should I run this test?" — emphasizing that system constraints, decision environments, and design flaws can render even statistically powered experiments incapable of answering the real business question.
Source
Key quotes
· 3 pulledThe experiment was technically sound, statistically powered but the experiment could never have answered the question the business was asking, despite putting enormous efforts to run it.
Especially as AI is making strides and experimenting is becoming easier by the day, the question is, 'Should I run this test?'
Before running an experiment, I...
You might also wanna read

Why AI-Driven Synthetic User Testing Fails: A Case for Real UX Research
The article argues against the growing trend of companies using AI-driven "synthetic" user testing as a replacement for real UX research wit

MIT Study: 95% of Enterprise AI Pilots Fail Due to Organizational Gaps, Not Technology Flaws
MIT research reveals that 95% of enterprise AI pilots fail to deliver measurable business impact, not because the technology is flawed, but

Experiment shows AI models fail to run profitable radio stations autonomously
Andon Labs conducted an experiment where four popular AI models (Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, and Grok) were tasked with running profitable radi

Experiment shows AI models fail to run profitable radio stations autonomously
Andon Labs conducted an experiment where four popular AI models (Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, and Grok) were tasked with running profitable radi
GPT-5 fails basic reasoning test: Can't count the 'b's in "blueberry"
The article discusses the release of GPT-5 by OpenAI and the widespread disappointment in the AI community and beyond regarding its performa
Why AI visibility dashboards sell false precision — and what brands should demand instead
A software engineer critically examines the emerging category of AI visibility measurement tools, arguing that these dashboards present prec
Why independent AI evaluation startups consistently fail
This article explores why independent evaluation (eval) startups in the AI space consistently fail, outside of the safety evals niche. The a
thomasliao.com·14d agoWhy independent AI evaluation startups consistently fail
This article explores why independent evaluation (eval) startups in the AI space consistently fail, outside of the safety evals niche. The a
thomasliao.com·14d ago
Comments
Sign in to join the conversation.
No comments yet. Be the first.