Emmy editing bias against mockumentaries: Why Abbott Elementary's Reggie Dinkins deserves a nomination
By
Erik Adams
Summary
The article discusses the Emmy Awards' historical bias against mockumentary-style comedies in the editing category. It notes that only three mockumentaries have been nominated for editing since 2006, with only one win (The Office in 2013). The piece argues that Reggie Dinkins, an editor on Abbott Elementary (which uses mockumentary style), deserves recognition and an Emmy nomination for editing. It highlights how the editing craft in mockumentaries is uniquely challenging due to the need to simulate unscripted, documentary-style footage while maintaining comedic timing and narrative coherence.
Source

Key quotes
· 3 pulledIt's been 13 years since a mockumentary won an Emmy for editing.
It's a curious bias on a pure numbers level, considering how many comedies took on the language of nonfiction film and unscripted TV in the wake of The Office's and Modern Family's popularity.
Only two other mockumentaries, Modern Family and What We Do In The Shadows, have been nominated in the category.
You might also wanna read
How Editor Kyle Gilman Maximizes Jokes Within Broadcast TV's Tight Constraints on 'The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins'
Editor Kyle Gilman discusses the editing process for NBC's comedy series "The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins," explaining how strict broadc
Tracy Morgan and 'Reggie Dinkins' Writers Honored with Roomy Award at Vulture Festival
A Vulture Festival panel at Tribeca Festival featuring Tracy Morgan, the creators, and writers of 'The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins' who
Erika Alexander Accepts IndieWire Maverick Award, Says She's Been Calling Herself a Maverick for Years
Erika Alexander, star of "The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins," accepted the Maverick Award at IndieWire Honors with humor and self-awarenes
Robert Carlock and Sam Means Honor Erika Alexander at IndieWire Honors Spring 2026
The article covers the IndieWire Honors Spring 2026 ceremony, which will celebrate creators and stars of the year's best television series.
Tracy Morgan and 'Reggie Dinkins' Creative Team Discuss Balancing Jokes with Character Depth in New Comedy Series
An article about the making of the comedy series "The Rise and Fall of Reggie Dinkins," co-created by Sam Means and Robert Carlock, starring
Erika Alexander on 'The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins' and Receiving the Maverick Award at IndieWire Honors
Erika Alexander, star of 'The Fall and Rise of Reggie Dinkins' and best known for her iconic role as Maxine Shaw on 'Living Single,' will re
Comments
Sign in to join the conversation.
No comments yet. Be the first.
