Wikipedia's Approach to Fringe Theories: Using Flat Earth as a Case Study
By
duncanjbrown
Baker's choice. Dense with flavour, light on filler.
Summary
This Wikipedia essay explains why Wikipedia cannot definitively claim the Earth is not flat, using the Flat Earth theory as a metaphor to examine ten common argument types used by advocates of fringe concepts. The article provides guidance for Wikipedia editors and administrators on recognizing and defusing these arguments while maintaining neutrality and adhering to Wikipedia's policies on verifiability and reliable sources.
Key quotes
· 4 pulledIt is unlikely that you will ever happen upon an editor who will argue that Wikipedia cannot claim that the Earth is not flat.
This page describes techniques to recognise and defuse arguments used by fringe authors.
Using the Flat Earth example as a metaphor, this essay will examine ten types of arguments commonly used by advocates of fringe concepts.
The article advises the neutrally-minded editor or administrator on how to defuse fringe arguments.
You might also wanna read
Teaching AI literacy: Why educators should focus on critical thinking, not tool usage
An educator describes a classroom exercise where students used generative AI to redesign a Moroccan road safety campaign. While students qui
timeshighereducation.com·3d ago
Opinion: AI reliance may erode critical thinking and learning skills
A passionate opinion piece arguing against the common claim that non-AI users will be left behind. The author contends the opposite: those w
migrainebrain.bearblog.dev·1mo ago
Why Authentic Education Must Go Beyond AI-Generated Content
This commentary argues that authentic education must transcend the mere production of words and content, especially in an era where AI can g
ncregister.com·1mo ago
Almanac: An Open Wiki Platform for Collaborative Knowledge Building
Almanac is an open knowledge base and wiki platform that allows communities to collaboratively build and maintain deep knowledge repositorie
openalmanac.org·1mo ago
How to Document Processes to Avoid Re-learning Them Later
The article discusses the importance of documenting processes to avoid having to re-learn them later. The author shares a personal experienc
ellanew.com·3mo ago
Carl Sagan's Baloney Detection Kit: Critical Thinking Tools for Distinguishing Science from Pseudoscience
The article discusses Carl Sagan's "Baloney Detection Kit," a set of critical thinking tools he developed to help distinguish science from p
openculture.com·3mo ago