What's a 9.9/10 game to you, almost perfect with one minor gripe?

To me it's Witcher 3. The story, side quests, characters and visuals are all top notch, the only gripe I have is the combat. Often times when I want to do a short swing, geralt does a long lunge instead and I ended up getting hit. If the movement was less clunky it would be a perfect 10/10.