Applying Frankfurt's Theory of Bullshit to AI Discourse
By
Kate Davies Designs
Pulled from the oven just right. Trustworthy, fact-dense, deeply satisfying.
Summary
This article explores the concept of "bullshit" as defined by philosopher Harry Frankfurt — utterances indifferent to truth, distinct from lying — and applies it to the discourse surrounding artificial intelligence. The author argues that much of the hype, marketing, and commentary about AI constitutes "knitting bullshit," where claims are made without genuine concern for accuracy or reality. The piece critically examines how AI companies, journalists, and enthusiasts generate misleading narratives that obscure what AI can and cannot actually do, drawing parallels between Frankfurt's philosophical framework and contemporary tech culture.
Key quotes
· 3 pulledBullshit is an utterance with 'a lack of connection to concern with truth' and an 'indifference to how things really are.'
While a liar displays an under...
It is important to understand that bullshit is, in its peculiarly execrable nature, materially different to a lie.
You might also wanna read
AI hype vs. reality: The failed promises and hollow outputs plaguing the industry
The article critiques the gap between AI hype and reality, highlighting common frustrations with AI-generated content that feels robotic and
theconversation.com·3d agoBook Criticizing AI's Impact on Truth Caught Using AI-Generated Quotes
A book about how AI shapes perceptions of reality faced controversy for using AI-generated quotes. The article (from WIRED) covers the irony
AI Is Not Artificial: It's Accumulated Human Thought Reflected Through Machines
The article argues that "AI" is a misleading term because artificial intelligence is not truly alien or fake — it is accumulated human thoug
AI in Literature: Three Controversies Highlight the Tension Between Technology and Creative Writing
The article discusses the growing tension between artificial intelligence and the literary world, highlighting three recent controversies: N
Book About AI and Truth Contains AI-Generated Fabricated Quotes, Author Admits
Steve Rosenbaum's book "The Future of Truth," which examines how AI distorts perceptions of reality, faced controversy when The New York Tim
The Uncanny Valley of AI Writing: How Algorithmic Language Is Infiltrating Everyday Communication
The article explores how AI-generated writing has become pervasive in everyday communications, from text messages to professional correspond
