'The Five-Star Weekend' Review: A Refreshingly Murder-Free Escape on Peacock
A review of Peacock's limited series 'The Five-Star Weekend,' an adaptation of Elin Hilderbrand's novel starring Jennifer Garner. The critic praises the show for breaking the 'prestige TV murder mystery' trend (popularized by Big Little Lies and The White Lotus) by offering a grounded, character-driven drama about female friendship and midlife reinvention without a dead body or crime as a plot device. The series follows Hollis Shaw (Garner), a food blogger who, after her husband's sudden death, gathers four friends from different eras of her life for a Nantucket weekend. The review highlights the refreshing lack of sensational violence and the show's focus on authentic emotional stakes.
Key quotes
I'm so glad 'The Five-Star Weekend' doesn't have a dead body.
Partly a hook (as if the scenery and stars aren't enough), partly a karmic comeuppance (we can't bear to watch these people enjoy their riches undisturbed), a suspicious death is the unwritten rule of otherwise escapist entertainment.
The show is a reminder that not every story about wealthy people in beautiful places needs a corpse to be compelling.
From the article
You might also wanna read
Review: Peacock's 'The Five Star Weekend' serves up schmaltzy but charming beach-read adaptation with Jennifer Garner
A review of Peacock's adaptation of Elin Hilderbrand's novel "The Five Star Weekend," starring Jennifer Garner as a recently widowed food bl
avclub.com·1h ago
'The Five-Star Weekend' Review: Peacock's Grief Drama-Starring Jennifer Garner Is Knowingly Silly Fun
A review of Peacock's adaptation of Erin Hilderbrand's novel 'The Five-Star Weekend,' starring Jennifer Garner as a recent widow who gathers
IndieWire·1h ago
The Five Star Weekend Review: Jennifer Garner's Peacock Drama Lacks the Thrills It Promises
A review of Peacock's series "The Five Star Weekend" starring Jennifer Garner. The show is described as a "Wine Mom Mystery" that looks prom
TVLine·3d ago
'The Five Star Weekend' Cast Guide: Jennifer Garner and Timothy Olyphant Lead Peacock's Nantucket Series
A cast guide for Peacock's new series "The Five Star Weekend," based on Elin Hilderbrand's 2023 novel. The show follows food blogger Hollis
Decider·4h ago
'The Five Star Weekend': Jennifer Garner's New Drama Series Based on Elin Hilderbrand Novel — How to Stream
A promotional article about Jennifer Garner's new show "The Five Star Weekend," based on Elin Hilderbrand's 2023 novel. The drama follows Ho
Decider·2h ago
Peacock's 'The Five Star Weekend' Is a Pleasantly Shallow Adaptation of Elin Hilderbrand's Novel
A review of Peacock's adaptation of Elin Hilderbrand's 'The Five Star Weekend,' which follows a culinary influencer who gathers her closest
vulture.com·3h ago
Comments
Sign in to join the conversation.
No comments yet. Be the first.