Why Pre-Push Hooks Are Better Than Pre-Commit Hooks for Software Development
By
todsacerdoti
The bagel they save for the regulars. Don't skim, savour.
Summary
The article critiques pre-commit hooks in software development, arguing they are fundamentally broken because they block developers from committing code, create friction in the workflow, and can be bypassed. The author suggests using pre-push hooks instead, which allow developers to commit locally but prevent pushing broken code to shared repositories. The article uses a Rust project example to demonstrate how pre-commit hooks interrupt the natural development flow and proposes pre-push hooks as a better alternative that maintains code quality without disrupting the commit process.
Key quotes
· 5 pulledpre-commit hooks are fundamentally broken
They tell me I need to have 'proper formatting'
use pre-push hooks instead
pre-commit hooks block developers from committing code
pre-push hooks allow developers to commit locally but prevent pushing broken code to shared repositories
You might also wanna read
Cursor: AI-Powered Code Editor for Enhanced Developer Productivity
Cursor is an AI-powered code editor designed to significantly boost developer productivity by integrating AI assistance directly into the co
Haystack: AI-Powered Code Review Platform That Turns Pull Requests into Clear Narratives
Haystack is an AI-native code review platform that transforms pull request reviews from confusing jigsaw puzzles into clear narrative storie
Cline: AI-Powered Autonomous Coding Assistant for Visual Studio Code
Cline is an AI-powered autonomous coding agent for VS Code that can understand code context, generate code, answer questions, and perform co
Coddo: A Task-First Software Development Tool with AI Integration
Coddo is a task-first software development tool that differs from traditional IDEs like VS Code by organizing work around tasks rather than
Warp Platform: Terminal and Orchestration Tools for Building Coding Agents Locally and in the Cloud
Warp is a terminal platform designed specifically for building and running coding agents, offering both local and cloud-based capabilities.
Zed Code Editor Reaches 1.0 After Rebuilding from Scratch Without Electron
Zed, a new code editor built from scratch by the creators of Atom, has reached version 1.0. The team abandoned the Electron/web technology a
