The Farm Security Administration's 'Killed Negatives': Examining the Suppressed Photographs of the Great Depression
By
nomagicbullet
Crackling crust, pillowy middle. The kind of bagel that earns a second cup of coffee.
Summary
The article examines the history of the Farm Security Administration's photography program during the Great Depression, focusing on the practice of 'killing' photographs by hole-punching negatives. Of the 270,000 images commissioned to document rural America, more than a third were intentionally marked for destruction or suppression. The piece explores why certain images were preserved while others were eliminated, examining the political, aesthetic, and ideological factors that shaped this photographic archive and created an 'unknowable void' in the historical record.
Key quotes
· 5 pulledOf the 270,000 photographs commissioned by the US Farm Security Administration to document the Great Depression, more than a third were 'killed'.
One of the so-called 'killed negatives' that were hole punched by FSA staff to indicate that they should not be printed.
Begun as part of the alphabet soup of Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal policies, the Farm Security Administration (FSA) had been tasked with resettling struggling farmers onto more fertile ground.
Erica X Eisen examines the history behind this hole-punched archive and the unknowable void at its center.
Untitled photograph by Carl Mydans, 1935, possibly depicting a farm in Prince George's County, Maryland.
You might also wanna read
Forgotten Faces: Examining 1950s Mugshots from Small-Town America
An article from The Appendix that examines historical mugshots from a small town (New Castle, PA), focusing on the story of Floyd M. Armstro
Barwy Powstania 1944: A Colorized Photographic Collection of the Warsaw Uprising
A collection of 100 carefully colorized photographs from the Warsaw Uprising of 1944, created under the supervision of historians and Warsaw

Unseen 1970s photographs of East London squatters discovered after photographer's death at 99
After filmmaker Derek Smith sorted through the belongings of his late friend Joyce Edwards (who died at 99 in 2023), he discovered over 100
The Medici Method: How Renaissance Bankers Used Financial Power to Transform Art, Science, and Politics
The article examines the Medici family of Florence, who transformed from bankers to political and cultural leaders during the Renaissance. I
Renaissance Artists as Entrepreneurs: Business Management in the Art World
This article examines how Renaissance artists like Perugino, Raphael, Tintoretto, and Michelangelo operated not just as creators but as entr
italianartfortravelers.com·12h agoLa pasión por "Il Trovatore" de Verdi en la Lima del siglo XIX: el regreso de la ópera italiana en 1863
El artículo recuerda cómo en mayo de 1863, el público limeño esperó con gran anticipación la llegada de una compañía lírica italiana contrat
