Netflix's 'Voicemails for Isabelle' Restores Faith in Romantic Comedies
By
Anna Menta
Summary
The article is a personal essay/review comparing two Netflix romantic comedies: "Office Romance" (starring Jennifer Lopez and Brett Goldstein) and "Voicemails for Isabelle." The author found "Office Romance" technically well-made but emotionally hollow, leading them to question their love of rom-coms. However, "Voicemails for Isabelle" restored their faith in the genre by delivering genuine emotional connection and romantic chemistry that "Office Romance" lacked. The piece argues that true rom-com magic comes from authentic emotional stakes, not just sharp writing or star power.
Source
DeciderNetflix's 'Voicemails for Isabelle' Restores Faith in Romantic Comediesdecider.comKey quotes
· 4 pulledAll love to Jennifer Lopez and Brett Goldstein, but I simply did not care about their relationship in Office Romance.
The jokes were sharp. The script was smart. The supporting cast was stacked. I laughed. I had fun. But when JLo and BGold kissed, I felt absolutely nothing.
Maybe, I thought, I'm just not as into rom-coms as I thought I was. Maybe I'm not the romantic I used to be.
Then I watched Voicemails for Isabelle, another new Netflix romantic comedy that began streaming today.
You might also wanna read
'Office Romance' Review: Jennifer Lopez and Brett Goldstein Star in Netflix Raunchy Workplace Comedy
A review of Netflix's 'Office Romance' starring Jennifer Lopez and Brett Goldstein. The film follows a corporate CEO who falls for her lawye
Deadline·14d ago
Voicemails For Isabelle: Leah McKendrick's Netflix Film Revives Rom-Com and Dramedy Genres
Writer-director Leah McKendrick's new Netflix film Voicemails For Isabelle revives the romantic comedy and tearjerking dramedy genres, putti
The A.V. Club·20h ago
Office Romance Review: A Formulaic Netflix Rom-Com Elevated by Betty Gilpin's Performance
A review of Netflix's "Office Romance," a rom-com starring Jennifer Lopez and Brett Goldstein. The reviewer notes the film is better than it
IndieWire·14d ago
Zoey Deutch Stars in Netflix Rom-Com 'Voicemails for Isabelle' About Grief and Sisterhood
Zoey Deutch stars as Jill, a woman grieving the death of her beloved sister Isabelle, in Leah McKendrick's upcoming Netflix romantic comedy
IndieWire·1mo ago
'Office Romance' Review: Jennifer Lopez Returns to Romcom Form in Breezy Workplace Comedy
A review of Ol Parker's romantic comedy "Office Romance," starring Jennifer Lopez as airline CEO Jackie Cruz and Brett Goldstein as her new
Variety·14d ago
Netflix Announces June 2026 Lineup: New Originals and Classic Rom-Coms
Netflix announces its June 2026 lineup of new shows and films, including original romantic comedies "Office Romance" and "Voicemails for Isa
Variety·22d ago