Why older, imperfect American flags had more character than modern designs
By
Works in Progress, Ned Donovan
Hot, fresh, and worth queueing round the block for.
Summary
The article argues that modern, well-designed American flags lack the character and historical authenticity of older, "uglier" flags. It uses the historical example of Thuggees in early modern India as a framing device, suggesting that like those craftsmen, flag-making was once a more organic, imperfect process. The piece critiques contemporary design sensibilities that prioritize sleekness and uniformity over the messy, lived-in quality that gave older flags their meaning and charm.
Key quotes
· 3 pulledMost flags used to be ugly. They were probably better that way.
Good design is ruining American flags
Each autumn in early modern India, certain men drifted out of the central provinces to take up their craft.
You might also wanna read

Trump Mobile T1 phone still undelivered, flag design accuracy questioned
A critical, sarcastic article about Trump Mobile's ongoing failure to deliver its promised T1 phone to reviewers. The company announced ship
Can 18th-Century Democratic Institutions Survive 21st-Century Technology?
This article examines whether America's 18th-century constitutional design and democratic institutions can withstand the challenges posed by
U.S. Coast Guard Abandons Plan to Make Swastika Official Mascot After Backlash
The U.S. Coast Guard has reversed its controversial plan to reclassify the swastika from a hate symbol to its official mascot after facing s

The Political Power of St George's Cross Flags in English Public Spaces
This article examines the proliferation of St George's flags across England and explores how design elements like flags can influence politi
Can 18th-Century Democratic Institutions Survive 21st-Century Technology?
This article examines whether America's 18th-century constitutional design and democratic institutions can withstand the challenges posed by
Can 18th-Century American Institutions Survive 21st-Century Technology?
This article examines whether America's 18th-century constitutional design, rooted in Enlightenment ideals of "reflection and choice," can w
