US Judge Withdraws Decision Due to AI-Like Errors in Legal Opinion
By
Jess Weatherbed
A second-rack bagel that's nearly first-rack. Tasty stuff.
Summary
A US district court judge withdrew his decision in a biopharma securities case after lawyers identified fake quotes and erroneous case information in his opinion, resembling errors linked to AI tools. The judge's decision, which denied a lawsuit dismissal request from CorMedix, contained misstated outcomes from other cases and other inaccuracies.
Key quotes
· 3 pulledA US district court judge has withdrawn his decision in a biopharma securities case after lawyers noted that his opinion referenced fake quotes and other erroneous case information.
These citation errors include misstating the outcomes in three other cases, and 'numerous instances' of inaccuracies.
Mistakes mirroring errors in other legal cases that have been attributed to artificial intelligence tools.
You might also wanna read
Judge Alsup criticizes Anthropic's $1.5B settlement as inadequate for pirated book claims
US District Judge William Alsup criticized a proposed $1.5 billion settlement between Anthropic and authors over the AI company's unauthoriz
arstechnica.com·8mo ago
The Ongoing Problem of AI-Generated False Citations in Court Filings
This article examines the persistent problem of lawyers submitting court filings containing AI-hallucinated case citations, despite increase
India's Supreme Court Investigates Judge's Use of Fake AI-Generated Court Orders
India's Supreme Court has threatened legal consequences after discovering that a junior judge in Andhra Pradesh used fake AI-generated court
bbc.com·3mo ago
California Courts Use AI to Draft Orders Without Disclosing to Litigants, Investigation Finds
A CalMatters/KPBS investigation reveals that AI tools are being used to draft tentative judicial orders and research memos in two of Califor
techtimes.com·13h ago
FDA's AI for Drug Approvals Found to Fabricate Studies
The FDA's AI system, designed to expedite drug approvals, has been discovered to generate fake studies and misrepresent research, raising co
The Onion·10mo ago
California courts test AI tool for drafting orders, raising transparency concerns in criminal cases
Two of California's largest courts (Los Angeles and Riverside counties) are piloting an AI tool called Learned Hand that can draft orders an
calmatters.org·1d ago