The Threat of AI to the Human Act of Writing and Thinking
By
Dan Chiasson
Kettled twice. Extra chewy, extra trustworthy.
Summary
The article explores how AI, particularly tools like Google's "Help Me Write," threatens the fundamental human act of writing by offering shortcuts through the natural gaps and impasses inherent in the writing process. The author argues that AI's ability to generate language bypasses the essential struggle of thinking that gives writing its meaning, making contemporaneous self-reflexivity a necessary precondition for anyone writing about AI today. The piece critiques the dehumanizing effect of AI on creative and intellectual work, emphasizing the need to actively preserve thinking as the medium in which language is generated.
Key quotes
· 4 pulledI would prefer not to write sentences that track their own emergence from thought; I don't like the kind of faddish writing that does this, this very thing that I am doing
now that I feel I must actively preserve thinking as the medium in which language is generated, against Google's satanic offer to 'Help Me Write'
One of the most dehumanizing effects of AI is the short cuts it offers through the gaps and impasses intrinsic to the act of writing
from behind the blinking cursor marking my every pause and hesitation in writing this sentence, a serpent waits to strike
You might also wanna read
How AI-Generated Language Threatens Authentic Human Communication
The article explores the erosion of meaningful language in an age of AI-generated text and cliché. It examines how the rise of large languag

The Importance of Manual Writing and Coding in the Age of AI
The article argues against over-reliance on AI for writing and coding, advocating for maintaining human thinking skills and manual craftsman
The Challenges of Mistaking AI-Generated Text for Human Writing
The article discusses the discomfort and challenges of interacting with LLM-generated text, particularly when it is mistaken for human-writt
The Ethics of AI Transparency in Writing: When and How to Disclose AI Usage
The article discusses the ethical implications and social perceptions of using AI language models for writing, particularly focusing on the

The Problem with Sycophantic Language in Human-Chatbot Conversations
The article discusses a concerning phenomenon where users adopt sycophantic, overly deferential language when interacting with AI chatbots,
The frustration of AI-generated responses replacing genuine human expertise
The article describes the author's frustrating experiences with AI-generated content replacing genuine human interaction and expertise. Two
The frustration of AI-generated responses replacing genuine human expertise
The article describes the author's frustrating experiences with AI-generated content replacing genuine human interaction and expertise. Two
