'Maddie's Secret' Review: John Early's Directorial Debut Is a Sincere Queer Melodrama, Not a Parody
By
Sam Bodrojan
Hot, fresh, and worth queueing round the block for.
Summary
John Early's directorial debut 'Maddie's Secret' premiered at TIFF 2025. The film, which Early also writes and stars in, is a pastiche of basic-cable TV movies that defies expectations by being a devastatingly sincere high melodrama with a studied queer sensibility, rather than a parody or comedy. Magnolia Pictures will release it in June 2026.
Key quotes
· 3 pulled'Maddie's Secret' is probably not what you are expecting.
Comedian John Early's directorial debut, ostensibly a pastiche of basic-cable TV movies, is not a parody, or a satire, or even a comedy.
Instead, it turns out a devastatingly sincere high melodrama with a studied queer sensibility.
You might also wanna read
'Sweet Magnolias' Season 4 Recap: Key Plot Points to Remember Before Season 5 Premieres on Netflix
A recap of Sweet Magnolias Season 4 events ahead of the Season 5 premiere on Netflix (June 11, 2025). The article reminds viewers of key plo
Decider·13d ago
Sweet Magnolias Season 5 Premiere: JoAnna Garcia Swisher Reacts to Maddie's Shocking Firing
The Sweet Magnolias Season 5 premiere features a shocking twist where Maddie is fired from her job, a development that star JoAnna Garcia Sw
TVLine·6d ago
Jennifer Lawrence to Star in and Produce Apple Rom-Com 'One Month Mark'
Jennifer Lawrence is set to star in and produce a new romantic comedy titled "One Month Mark" for Apple Original Films. The film is based on
Variety·6d ago
'Girls Like Girls' Review: Hayley Kiyoko's Feature Debut Offers a Conventional but Refreshing Queer Coming-of-Age Story
Hayley Kiyoko's directorial debut 'Girls Like Girls' adapts her 2015 viral pop song and subsequent YA novel into a feature film. The movie t
Variety·14h ago'Girls Like Girls' Review: Hayley Kiyoko's Feature Debut Offers a Conventional but Refreshing Queer Coming-of-Age Story
Hayley Kiyoko's directorial debut 'Girls Like Girls' adapts her 2015 viral pop song and subsequent YA novel into a feature film. The movie t
variety.com·14h ago
Apple Acquires Romantic Comedy 'One Month Mark' Starring Jennifer Lawrence
Apple Original Films has won a competitive auction for the romantic comedy spec script 'One Month Mark' by Sophie Fleur de Bruijn, with Jenn
Deadline·6d ago
Deadline's 'It Starts on the Page' Features 'The Morning Show' Season 4 Script "The Parent Trap" With Showrunner Foreword
Deadline's "It Starts on the Page" series highlights the Season 4 script of The Morning Show titled "The Parent Trap," with a foreword by sh
Deadline·1d ago