Why Forcing a Bell Curve on College Grades Is Misguided
By
Ray Schroeder
If you only eat one bagel today, this is the bagel.
Summary
The article argues against the practice of grade inflation crackdowns and the notion that too many A's in college classes is a problem. The author contends that well-designed courses with quality rubrics should naturally yield higher grades, and that forcing a bell curve distribution of grades is misguided—more appropriate for manufacturing than education. The piece references Harvard and Yale's recent scrutiny of grade inflation and connects it to broader concerns about AI tools enabling student cheating, pushing back against the idea that high grades necessarily indicate lowered standards.
Key quotes
· 3 pulledIt is my long-held belief that striving to have a near-equal number of A's and F's in a college class is a grossly misdirected goal.
This always seemed to me to be better applied to a sorting guideline for assembly-line manufacturing.
If viable, relevant, up-to-date learning outcomes are well assessed, then higher grades on average are commendable.
You might also wanna read
EU Council adopts first-ever framework for science diplomacy
The Council of the EU has adopted its first-ever framework for science diplomacy, based on a European Commission proposal. The framework aim
Chicago Teachers Union members reject dues increase for political campaign funding
Chicago Teachers Union members voted overwhelmingly against a proposed amendment that would have raised union dues to fund political campaig
A Marxist case for democratic socialist economic planning
This article is a transcript of a Marxist Winter School presentation by Vincent R. Beaudoin arguing for the necessity of a socialist planned
Tightening US visa rules threaten international researchers and scientific competitiveness
International scientists in the US are facing worsening visa bottlenecks marked by prolonged administrative processing, new fee and lottery
Privy Council (United Kingdom): Overview of the Advisory Body to the Monarch
The article provides a comprehensive overview of His Majesty's Most Honourable Privy Council, the formal advisory body to the British monarc
OMB's Proposed Rule Would Allow Political Appointees to Override Peer Review for Federal Research Grants
This article analyzes the implications of OMB's proposed Federal Financial Assistance Rule (OMB-2026-0034), which would allow political appo
